Dermatology – A Medical Specialty of Perpetual Failure
I went to yet another dermatologist the other day and received yet
another diagnosis. I have been told by dermatologists that I have
rosacea, that I don’t have rosacea but have seb derm, and now I
have
been told that I have both.
This last dermatologist I saw seemed to be a very pleasant person,
and she seemed to be listening to what I told her regarding my
previous visits to other dermatologists and the various treatments
I’ve tried. She even listened when I told her that I felt my
skin
problems could be induced by environmental causes (I first noticed
the redness and dryness about 2 months after moving into a new
apartment), stress, sleep problems, and diet (I mentioned the recent
research that indicated people not exposed to western diets have no
skin problems like acne and that high carb/high glycemic diets may
induce these skin problems.) I asked her what she thought of me
pursuing allergy testing, changing my diet, taking stress reductions
classes, etc. Her attitude was that it wouldn’t hurt but she
didn’t
seem to think it would do much good.
So after all that what did she do? Her face lit up and she
said, "I’ve got a great new topical medication for your seb
derm."
I said, "I bet your going to prescribe Protopic or Elidel."
That
kind of took the wind out of her sails. She said she thought I
should try Elidel and she gave me some samples. I’ve never tried
the
immunomodulator drugs. From what I’ve heard they work about as
well
as topical steroids but without the side effects. For the rosacea
she prescribed minocycline, something that’s been used for years.
As I was walking out of her office I realized how hopeless it is to
look for solutions from dermatologists. The depressing reality is
that the very best this profession has to offer is temporary relief
from some of the symptoms of these skin problems. These
dermatologists don’t know what causes these diseases (and
don’t seem
to care) and have no clue as to what might cure them. The approach
they take is like prescribing an aspirin for a brain tumor. The
aspirin might temporarily relieve the pain, but the brain tumor is
still there.
Because those in the field of dermatology ignore the possible causes
of skin diseases, it wouldn’t surprise me at all if this field
never
cured a single skin disease from now until the end of time. But this
makes sense because the list of illnesses that modern medicine can
cure, beyond a few bacterial infections, is practically nil. And
often the drugs that dermatologists prescribe are worse than useless,
as they cause more harm than good. (Look at steroid induced rosacea
as one example.) I don’t think there’s a chance in hell this
topical
crap and antibiotics are going to solve our skin problems, but I
guarantee you it will cause other problems for some percentage of the
people who use them.
The moral of this story is that we will never find a solution to our
skin problems by going to dermatologists. They have absolutely no
financial interest in curing any of these diseases. This field has
changed very little in the last 50 years. As long as you keep coming
back, the dermatologists and drug companies are happy. The fact that
you aren’t makes no difference.
Our only hope is to pursue other avenues. I strongly recommend
people look into things like diet, stress, sleeping patterns and
their environment. I don’t think you can find a cure until you
find
a cause. So try to figure out what is causing your skin problems.
Look for any changes in your life that might have caused your skin
problems.
I have no answers except to say that looking to your dermatologist
for a cure will probably always be completely futile. It is a waste
of time, money and hope. You have to find the cure because no one in
the field of dermatology will. And after all, you care alot more
about your skin then your dermatologist ever will.
Dave
March 4th, 2004 at 4:18 pm
I agree 100%…I think having sebderm or rosacea or both, is
hopeless. In my personal opinion, I honestly believe stress is a
serious trigger. When I first noticed the symptons, my mother had
just passed away, I had been fed up with my job for a while, I then
changed jobs only to jump from the frying pan into the fire…and my
sebderm just got worse and worse.
I visited 4 dermatologists in as many months…one said psoriasis,
the other said sebderm, the other couldn’t really make up her mind,
and the last one was formal: no psoriasis: SEBDERM. And she hadn’t
seen many people before in which the condition was so bad…!
My husband was diagnozed with Non-Hodgkin’s lymphome in 1991. He is
all clear. He’s great, but having been through this malignant disease
then, he’s not very understanding about the sebderm: I just have to
learn to live with it! Fine, but, not always easy eh!
Lately, I don’t get the very bad flares anymore: Thank heaven! I have
a new job that I love, I’m no longer stressed out at work which is
bliss. When I do get some painful lesions, I just use a little bit of
a steroid cream (Advantan). Other than that, I make sure I moisturize
plenty. I can shower nowadays, but with lukewarm water only, not too
hot! Not too cold either…it’s a thin line for me. And I clean my
face with a special cleanser (Roc). I also use their moisturizer for
special atopic skin.
I also suffer regularly from redness, which is awkward. And then I
feel like I have a temperature. Sometimes I wonder if I don’t have
rosacea too?
For my hair, I alternate shampoos: Nizoral and others from the
supermarket.Some for dandruff, others plain ordinary.
I haven’t got a clue if I can buy Elidel or Protopic here…I have
only recently joined this group, and have spent some days reading
quite a few of the previous post.
We can learn a lot from each other. But still I am convinced that we
each have to try different things and stick to the one that is
helping us. What works for me might not work for someone else though.
Hilde in Belgium